Independence Hall

Essay

Originally the Pennsylvania State House, the eighteenth-century landmark associated with the Declaration of Independence and the U.S. Constitution came to be known as Independence Hall as it evolved from a workplace of government to a treasured shrine, tourist attraction, and World Heritage Site. Its history encompasses more than 275 years of struggles for freedom and public participation in creating, preserving, and debating the founding principles of the United States.

The history of Independence Hall dates to 1729, when the Pennsylvania Assembly authorized construction of “a House for the Assembly of this Province to meet in.” The site chosen, on Chestnut Street between Fifth and Sixth Streets, was then on the outskirts of Philadelphia and therefore pulled the city’s development westward.  In architectural style, the building that began construction in 1732 was Georgian—a common choice for American public buildings but also a statement of British elite culture at a time when Pennsylvanians were concerned about large in-migrations of Germans and Scots Irish.

Scull and Heap Map of Philadelphia, 1752
The Pennsylvania State House, with its added tower and steeple, depicted on a 1752 map by Nicholas Scull and George Heap (Library of Congress).

Assembly Speaker Andrew Hamilton led the committee to select the site and is credited with the building’s design, which closely resembled architectural pattern-book plans for English country houses. Edmund Woolley, a member of the Carpenters’ Company, supervised the craftsmen and laborers who built the structure, which was ready for use by the Assembly by 1736.  In 1749, the Assembly again called upon Woolley to add a tower and steeple to the south side of the building, thereby creating the building’s distinctive, church-like silhouette and providing a place to hang a new bell—the same bell that later became known as the Liberty Bell.

The Pennsylvania State House served many purposes in its first half-century, as the seat of provincial government, a banquet hall for occasions such as celebrations of birthdays of British monarchs, and a meeting place for learned societies such as the American Philosophical Society and the Library Company of Philadelphia. But its lasting place in American history was secured during the era of the American Revolution, when Pennsylvania’s central location and relatively moderate politics made Philadelphia the logical gathering place for the First and Second Continental Congresses.

State and National Governments

Despite resistance to independence by the Pennsylvania Assembly, the Second Continental Congress met in the State House beginning in May 1775, and in the east room on the first floor resolved to break from Great Britain on July 2, 1776, and approved the Declaration of Independence on July 4. Within the State House, Pennsylvania government also changed. In July 1776, a Pennsylvania Constitutional Convention produced a constitution regarded as the most democratic among all the former British colonies, and in 1780, the Pennsylvania Assembly passed the nation’s first law mandating the gradual abolition of slavery. The State House served as capital of both the state and national governments for the duration of the War for Independence, interrupted by the British occupation of Philadelphia in 1777-78, when the building served as jail and hospital ward for American prisoners.

A second hallmark event in the building’s history occurred in 1787, when the State House served as meeting place for the Constitutional Convention, which convened in May and completed its work on a new frame of government on September 17. Activity in and around the State House then shifted to whether Pennsylvania would ratify the document, and violent street confrontations occurred between supporters (Federalists) and dissenters. After lengthy public debates by a ratifying convention in the State House, focused on issues such as the lack of guarantees for individual rights, Pennsylvania became the second state (after Delaware) to ratify the U.S. Constitution.

The State House continued as the seat of Pennsylvania government through the 1790s, when Philadelphia also served as the nation’s capital, but became the “old” State House after Pennsylvania followed its westward-growing population by moving the state capital to Lancaster in 1799 and later to Harrisburg. When the federal government also left Philadelphia for the new District of Columbia in 1800, the old State House faced an uncertain future.  Through the 1790s and the early decades of the nineteenth century, the second floor gained a new purpose as the home of Charles Willson Peale’s Museum, which aimed to cultivate a new national culture through appreciation of the arts and natural sciences. But the building and square around it became surplus state property at risk of being sold for redevelopment as building lots.

Altered Architecture

paiting of Election Day, 1815
Election Day at the State House, 1815, by John Lewis Krimmel (Historical Society of Pennsylvania)

Philadelphians also showed little regard for the original fabric of the old State House when, in 1812, they allowed the structure’s wings and arched piazzas to be replaced by rows of brick buildings for city offices. However, when state proposals in 1813 and 1816 called for selling off the State House square, Philadelphia city officials acted to preserve the building and opened a period of local guardianship that continued until the mid-twentieth century. The city agreed to buy the building and square from the state in 1816, an act regarded as important in the history of historic preservation in the United States.

When the Marquis de Lafayette, a hero of the American Revolution, visited the United States in 1824, he was welcomed to Philadelphia at the old State House. In the process of planning this event, Philadelphians began to refer to the first-floor east room as “the Hall of Independence” and “Independence Hall”—a name that gradually came to be applied to the entire building. The surrounding square was named Independence Square in 1825, when the city also gave names of historic figures (Washington, Franklin, Rittenhouse, and Logan) to other squares. In 1828, Philadelphia City Councils also ordered a new steeple for the old State House and insisted that it resemble the original, which had rotted away four decades before.  Such actions reflected a growing dedication to preserving the memory of the American Revolution as the founding generation passed from the scene.

photgraph of Independence Hall's steeple
The Independence Hall steeple, reconstructed in 1828 (PhillyHistory.org)

As a public building associated with the nation’s founding events but surviving in the midst of a growing, industrializing city, Independence Hall served as a focal point for engaging the political, economic, and social issues of the nineteenth century. Other than the first-floor room where independence was declared, through the mid-nineteenth century the building housed courtrooms where judgments determined the freedom or loss of freedom for individuals accused of crimes; apprentices who sued for release from their contracts; and African Americans suspected of being fugitives from slavery.

Just Outside, Historic Gatherings

Outside in the square, laborers demonstrated for improved working conditions, immigrants demonstrated in sympathy with revolutions in Europe, and Frederick Douglass spoke against slavery in 1844.  In 1876, Susan B. Anthony and other women’s rights activists distributed a Declaration of Rights of Women. Independence Square remained a forum for public dissent until the early twentieth century, when the City of Philadelphia responded to a planned demonstration by the Industrial Workers of the World (IWW) by restricting activity to officially designated “patriotic purposes.” After the creation of Independence National Historical Park in the mid-twentieth century, the National Park Service tolerated demonstrations during the Civil Rights and Vietnam eras, but federal regulations subsequently placed new restrictions on the use of the square, especially following attacks on the United States on September 11, 2001.

Under the guardianship of Philadelphians, Independence Hall gradually transformed from a working government building to a national shrine, with traces of other local uses often erased in the process. The first-floor east room became a shrine to the founding fathers in 1854 under the sponsorship of nativist politicians, who gained control of the city government that year and created new City Council chambers on the second floor. During the Centennial celebration of 1876, the entire first floor of the building became the “National Museum,” featuring portraits and early-American artifacts. At the end of the century, when the City Councils left the building for the new City Hall, the Daughters of the American Revolution renovated and redecorated the second floor in Colonial Revival style. The despised “row buildings” that had flanked the central structure since 1812 were replaced by new, graceful archways that resembled the original piazzas and opened a view and passageway from Chestnut Street to the square.

With the building now fully dedicated to historic purposes, in the first decades of the twentieth century Philadelphians also advocated creating expanded parks to buffer the treasured landmark from its dense, heavily industrialized surroundings. They succeeded.  The resulting Independence Mall and Independence National Historical Park at mid-century led to demolition of six city blocks of buildings not regarded as “historic,” an urban renewal project that also opened a new era of professional stewardship by the National Park Service. Independence Hall gained additional recognition in 1979, when it was designated a World Heritage Site by the United Nations Educational, Scientific, and Cultural Organization (UNESCO).

Independence Hall, the scene of events of national and international importance, also influenced the development and redevelopment of its home city and served as an impetus for the growth of the region’s tourist industry. By the first decades of the twenty-first century, Independence Hall anchored a historic district devoted to tourism and civic education, including the National Constitution Center, the Liberty Bell Center, the Independence Visitor Center, the National Museum of American Jewish History, and a memorial to the President’s House and individuals enslaved there by George Washington. Surrounded and dwarfed by larger institutions, Independence Hall is accessible by guided tours led by the National Park Service. Expertly restored, it is experienced as a time capsule of the past, but it has many stories to tell.

Charlene Miresis Professor of History at Rutgers-Camden and the author of Independence Hall in American Memory(Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 2002). (Author information current at time of publication.)

Copyright 2012, Rutgers University.

Gallery

Scull and Heap Map of Philadelphia, 1752

Library of Congress

The early prominence of the Pennsylvania State House is portrayed in this map of "Philadelphia and Parts Adjacent," published by Philadelphia surveyors Nicholas Scull and George Heap. At the time of the map's creation, the new tower and steeple were not yet finished, so Heap created the drawing based upon construction plans.

The map indicates Philadelphia's original boundaries, from river to river and from South to Vine Streets - the extent of the city until its consolidation with Philadelphia County in 1854.

Election Day 1815

Historical Society of Pennsylvania

Philadelphians submitted their election day ballots through the windows of the old Pennsylvania State House in the early nineteenth century, when the building served the needs of city government. This depiction by John Lewis Krimmel portrays the tumult of political activity and Chestnut Street life in 1815, when the building also housed Charles Willson Peale's Museum on the second floor.

This scene records the lack of interest in preservation of the old State House, despite its historic associations. The building's steeple had rotted away by 1781 and had not yet been replaced. The original piazzas flanking the central structure had been demolished and replaced by rows of offices for the city and county government.

John Lewis Krimmel, a young German immigrant who specialized in genre scenes of Philadelphia street life, was among many artists who worked in the vicinity of the old State House. During these years, the prolific painter Thomas Sully had his studio in Philosophical Hall behind the State House and attracted a following of artists to his classes and sketch club.

Independence Hall steeple (1929 photograph)

PhillyHistory.org

In 1828, the Philadelphia City Councils decided to commission a new steeple for Independence Hall to replace the structure that had been removed in 1781. In the growing and industrializing city of the nineteenth century, city officials saw the need for a steeple that would house clocks to regulate time and a bell to sound alerts in case of fire.

Planning for the new steeple showed a growing regard for Independence Hall as a place of historic significance. Against the initial advice of the commissioned architect, William Strickland, the City Councils insisted that the new steeple should resemble the appearance of the old State House in 1776 as closely as possible.

A new restoration of the Independence Hall steeple was completed by Independence National Historical Park in 2012.

Plan for Public Buildings on Independence Square, 1870

PhillyHistory.org

By the second half of the nineteenth century, Philadelphia's city and county governments had long outgrown the eighteenth-century buildings on Independence Square. Deciding where to place a new City Hall presented a new opportunity for debate about the historical significance of Independence Hall and its square.

In 1870, architect John McArthur Jr. created this plan for a new City Hall that would have preserved Independence Hall (shown at the top of the plan) but none of the other buildings on the square. Ultimately, an election determined that the new City Hall should be placed in Center Square instead, and McArthur adapted his design for the City Hall that remains there today.

July 4, 1963

PhillyHistory.org

Public activities in and around Independence Hall serve as a continuing reminder of the significance of the events and ideals of the nation's founding. On July Fourth in 1963, at the height of the civil rights movement, mezzo soprano Doris Mayes, winner of a Marian Anderson Voice Scholarship, sang the national anthem. Addresses that year were given by Vice President Lyndon B. Johnson, Mayor James H.J. Tate, and City Representative Frederic R. Mann.

Queen Elizabeth at Independence Hall, 1976

PhillyHistory.org

By the time of the Bicentennial in 1976, National Park Service management had produced new research on the era of the American Revolution and a scientific, pristine restoration of Independence Hall. Queen Elizabeth toured the restored Assembly Room with the superintendent of Independence National Historical Park, Hobart Cawood.

ACT UP Demonstration, 1992

John J. Wilcox LGBT Archives of Philadelphia

Continuing a tradition of dissent in the shadow of Independence Hall, demonstrators in 1992 call attention to the AIDS crisis.

Related Topics

Themes

Time Periods

Locations

Essays

Artifacts

Related Reading

Greiff, Constance. Independence: The Creation of a National Park. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 1987. (Excerpt)

Mires, Charlene.  Independence Hall in American Memory. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 2002.

Mires, Charlene. “In the Shadow of Independence Hall: Vernacular Activities and the Meanings of Historic Places.” The Public Historian (Spring 1999): 49-64.

Mires, Charlene. “Slavery, Nativism, and the Forgotten History of Independence Hall.” Pennsylvania History: A Journal of Mid-Atlantic Studies (Autumn 2000): 481-502. (PDF)

Related Collections

Related Places

Backgrounders

Links

Connecting the Past with the Present, Building Community, Creating a Legacy